Asset Sale Vs Share Sale: Which is Best?

Comparing Asset Sale Vs Share Sale

An asset sale involves the purchase of both tangible and intangible business assets. The buyer can choose which assets it wants to acquire, which means they can be more selective in what they inherit. This also allows the buyer to choose which liabilities they acquire, which can minimise potential risks. 

In a share sale, the buyer acquires the shares in the business directly from the shareholders. Unlike an asset sale, there is no scope for cherry-picking with this approach. Instead, the buyer takes on all assets and liabilities in the purchase agreement. 

To discuss the merits of asset sale vs share sale, it’s useful to consider the potential positives and negatives of each strategy. This approach can minimise liabilities, add a greater degree of choice, and offer a clean break. Regarding the sale of assets, advantages and disadvantages become clear for both buyer and seller.    

Advantages to Seller

From the seller’s perspective there are a range of advantages to an asset sale. Firstly, warranties and guarantees come from the company itself and not individual shareholders. The seller can also choose which assets to include in the transaction and there will be less indemnities to the buyer as a result.

Broadly, there are fewer risks to the buyer with an asset sale, which can result in a quicker process for all parties. There are potential tax benefits, such as allowable losses on assets — which can reduce Capital Gains Tax. Additionally, if an asset is sold for less than its written-down value, an allowance can offset the resulting loss against income or gains.

Disadvantages to Seller

In the case of an asset sale, the main disadvantage is that liabilities are likely to stay with the seller. Ensuring that contracts, properties, employees etc remain in place can also be complex and time-consuming. Finally, there are potential additional tax charges, including corporation tax at the beginning and, later, when sale proceeds are either taken from the company or divided among shareholders.

Advantages to Buyer

During the sale of assets, advantages and disadvantages to the buyer are effectively the polar opposite of those of the seller. 

Firstly, any business liabilities are not usually the responsibility of the buyer, who can also pick and choose which assets to acquire. This also gives them the opportunity to consider tax implications for those assets. Finally, there may be some tax reliefs available, depending on what kind of assets are included in the purchase. 

Disadvantages to Buyer

Some assets, such as employment contracts, may need third party consent to complete the sale — which can take time and is not guaranteed to be agreed. While the buyer can pick and choose certain assets, this does not include the transfer of employees, so the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations (TUPE) obligations will need to be met. Similarly, if the party acquiring intends to change the nature of the business, any purchased assets may be liable for additional VAT which cannot be recouped.

Finally, there are also property factors to consider. Specifically, the tax burden could exceed stamp duty charges from a share sale. 

For sale of shares, advantages and disadvantages are distinct for both the buyer and seller. For buyers, a share sale can be a good way to explore new markets, but risks can increase. For sellers, the process can be simpler than an asset sale, but indemnities can increase. These factors can be simplified by seeking thorough legal guidance. 

Advantages to Seller

Firstly, a share sale offers a clean break to the seller, so any existing liabilities become the sole responsibility of the new ownership. Continuity is also easier as the business becomes a going concern and a range of tax reliefs may become available. These include:

• Substantial Shareholding Exemption (SSE): Under certain conditions, the party selling shares in a trading company may avoid corporation tax on gains, including ‘degrouping’ charges.
• Business Asset Disposal Relief: Officers or employees of the target company can enjoy a 10% CGT rate, capped at £1m, for share disposal gains.
• Share for Share Exchange: If payment for the share sale is in buyer’s shares or loan notes, selling shareholders might be able to delay the gain until they sell acquired shares or notes. 

A law firm with a specialism in mergers and acquisitions will be able to advise upon the sale and offer the best route to a timely and beneficial outcome. 

Disadvantages to Seller

In a share sale, the target company commonly assumes all liabilities. If directors are required to offer personal guarantees, this can expose them to personal liability. Additionally, part of the price might be held in trust or secured with a bank guarantee and the buyer might discount the price due to the higher risks involved. 

Regarding charges, retained assets could trigger taxes and ‘degrouping’ charges might occur due to prior asset transfers.

Advantages to Buyer

If the target company has an established brand, the buyer can benefit from this and buy into a profitable brand and market. Third-party consent might not be required for existing contracts and there are potential savings available. These savings include favourable stamp duty rates, and zero VAT.

Disadvantages to Buyer

There are relatively few disadvantages to the buyer with a share sale. The most obvious downside is the lengthy due diligence required to minimise the risk of inherited liabilities. Additionally, while the selling shareholders offer indemnities for company liabilities, there’s a possibility they might lack the means to fulfil these indemnifications when required.

Asset Sale Vs Share Sale: Which is Best?

Let Thursfields Take the Lead on Your Next Venture

There are advantages and disadvantages to share and asset sales depending upon what you’re looking to achieve. With so much to consider, it’s vital to work with someone who has a proven specialism in all aspects of commercial transactions. You’ll need someone who can adapt to your goals and move seamlessly between commercial, employment and real estate law. 

Thursfields is a full-service law firm that gets results. We offer practical solutions to mergers and acquisitions and have helped countless businesses from a range of sectors. Our experienced lawyers have facilitated multi million pound deals in both domestic and international spheres.

Whether you’re buying or selling, you can rely on our skilled team to take care of every detail. For comprehensive guidance that’s built around you, get in touch today.